Argentina vs Portugal Without Messi and Ronaldo: A Tactical Breakdown of Which Squad Reigns Supreme

by:TacticalEmma2 months ago
1.87K
Argentina vs Portugal Without Messi and Ronaldo: A Tactical Breakdown of Which Squad Reigns Supreme

Argentina vs Portugal Without Messi and Ronaldo: Who Comes Out on Top?

The Stakes of the Debate

Football fans love hypotheticals, and few are more tantalizing than comparing two footballing powerhouses stripped of their iconic leaders. With Lionel Messi and Cristiano Ronaldo now in the twilight of their careers, it’s time to assess: Which squad is stronger without them?

Argentina’s World Cup-Winning Core

Let’s start with Argentina, fresh off their 2022 World Cup triumph. Even without Messi, their attack boasts two “billion-dollar” strikers: Lautaro Martínez and Julián Álvarez. Both are clinical finishers with elite pressing ability—a nightmare for any defense.

Their midfield is where things get interesting. Enzo Fernández, Alexis Mac Allister, and Rodrigo De Paul form a relentless defensive unit capable of suffocating opponents. Leandro Paredes adds depth, though creativity might be a slight concern.

Defensively, they’re solid but not spectacular. Cristian Romero is a rock, but Nicolás Otamendi’s age shows at times. Thankfully, Emiliano Martínez (“Dibu”) is there to bail them out—arguably the best goalkeeper in this comparison.

Portugal’s Tactical Flexibility

Now, Portugal. Their defense is stacked: Rúben Dias (a colossus), João Cancelo, Nuno Mendes, and Diogo Dalot are all top-tier full-backs. Even without Pepe’s experience, this backline oozes quality.

Midfield is their crown jewel. Bruno Fernandes, Bernardo Silva, and Vitinha offer unmatched technicality, while Danilo Pereira provides steel. The “Parisian duo” of Manuel Ugarte and Matheus Nunes adds youthful energy.

Up front, Rafael Leão and João Félix are explosive but inconsistent. Diogo Jota’s return from injury could be a game-changer, but Portugal lacks a true No. 9—something Argentina doesn’t worry about.

Verdict: The Edge Goes To…

This isn’t straightforward. Argentina has the better goalkeeper and strike force, but Portugal’s midfield and defense might just tip the scales. If I had to choose? Portugal by a whisker, thanks to their balance and tactical versatility. But don’t @ me—this debate is deliciously subjective.

Agree? Disagree? Let me know in the comments.

TacticalEmma

Likes60.85K Fans3.79K

Hot comment (17)

WindyCityStats
WindyCityStatsWindyCityStats
2 months ago

No Messi, No Ronaldo, No Problem?

Let’s be real: Argentina’s attack is fire (Lautaro and Álvarez are beasts), but Portugal’s midfield is like a Swiss Army knife—Bruno Fernandes could probably pass the salt with a no-look assist. And that defense? Rúben Dias eats strikers for breakfast.

Sure, Dibu Martínez might save Argentina’s bacon, but Portugal’s balance is just chef’s kiss. Close call, but I’m siding with the Portuguese—though Argentinians will riot in the comments.

Hot take or cold truth? Fight me below.

703
26
0
2 months ago

Analista INTJ entra en modo calculadora

Sin Messi y CR7, esto es como comparar tapas sin jamón ibérico: ¡todas saben bien pero falta el umami!

Argentina tiene a Dibu (el arquero que hipnotiza penales) y dos delanteros que valen más que mi hipoteca. Pero Portugal… madre mía, ese mediocampo es como un reloj suizo hecho en Lisboa.

Veredicto final: Los lusos ganan… ¡por diferencia de un pelo de Otamendi!

¿Ustedes qué piensan? ¿O también les duele la cabeza de tanta táctica? 😂

366
51
0
GoleiroDados
GoleiroDadosGoleiroDados
1 month ago

Sem os dois mitos, quem leva a melhor?

Argentina tem o Dibu e dois atacantes de bilhão, mas Portugal tem um meio-campo que parece saído de um sonho de treinador. Se fosse um jogo de cartas, Portugal teria a mão mais equilibrada… mas nunca subestime a raça argentina!

E aí, torcedores, quem vocês acham que levaria essa batalha? Comentem abaixo e vamos esquentar o debate! 🔥

142
86
0
PemburuData
PemburuDataPemburuData
1 month ago

Portugal Lebih Kuat Sedikit! \n\nAnalisis dataku menunjukkan tanpa Messi & Ronaldo, Portugal unggul tipis! Midfield mereka (Bruno Fernandes dkk) seperti mesin well-oiled, sedangkan Argentina masih bergantung pada Dibu Martinez yang superhuman. \n\nFakta Lucu: Kalau dihilangkan salah satu bintangnya, Portugal tetap menang - mungkin karena mereka punya lebih banyak ‘Silva’ dalam tim! \n\nSetuju? Ayo debat di komen! #TanpaMessiRonaldo #AnalisisAsik

879
67
0
FootixAnalyste
FootixAnalysteFootixAnalyste
1 month ago

Sans leurs stars, qui domine ?

La question que tout le monde se pose : Portugal ou Argentine sans Messi et CR7 ? L’Argentine a son duo d’attaque en or (Martínez et Álvarez) et un gardien phénoménal (Dibu). Mais le Portugal répond avec une défense en béton (Dias, Cancelo…) et un milieu de terrain à faire pâlir d’envie (Bruno Fernandes, Bernardo Silva…).

Verdict perso : Le Portugal l’emporte… mais juste parce qu’ils ont plus de joueurs qui s’appellent « João ». 😆

Et vous, vous votez pour qui ? #DébatEpique

918
84
0
AnalystMax_MUC
AnalystMax_MUCAnalystMax_MUC
1 month ago

Wer braucht schon Superstars?

Ohne Messi und Ronaldo wird’s erst richtig spannend! Portugal punktet mit einer Wahnsinns-Mittelfeldreihe (Bruno Fernandes & Co.), während Argentinien auf seinen Weltmeister-Kern vertraut.

Mein Tipp: Portugal gewinnt 2-1, weil kreative Spielmacher > Torjäger. Aber hey, wer wettet dagegen? 😉

Was denkt ihr? Kommentiert eure Prognose!

749
14
0
ক্রিকেটবিদ

মেসি-রোনাল্ডো ছাড়া আসলেই কে শক্তিশালী?

আর্জেন্টিনা আর পর্তুগালের ম্যাচে মেসি আর রোনাল্ডো না থাকলে কে জিতবে? এই প্রশ্নের উত্তর দিতে গিয়ে আমার মাথা ঘুরে গেছে!

আর্জেন্টিনার স্ট্রাইকাররা লাউতারো আর আলভারেজ তো রীতিমতো ‘গোল মেশিন’। কিন্তু পর্তুগালের মিডফিল্ডার ব্রুনো ফার্নান্ডেজ আর বার্নার্দো সিলভা দেখে মনে হচ্ছে তারা বলকে জাদু করতে পারে!

চূড়ান্ত সিদ্ধান্ত: পর্তুগাল একটু এগিয়ে… কিন্তু ‘ডিবু’ মার্টিনেজ থাকলে আর্জেন্টিনাও সহজে হার মানবে না!

আপনাদের কী মনে হয়? নিচে কমেন্টে লড়াই শুরু করুন!

308
51
0
КиївськийТактик

Хто ж перемагає без легенд?

Без Мессі та Роналду це як борщ без сметани — щось не те! Але давайте подивимось:

Аргентина має класних нападників (Мартінес та Альварес), але їхній креатив у півзахисті — це як мобільний інтернет у селі: то є, то немає.

Португалія ж — це ціла фабрика талантів. Бруно Фернандеш і Бернарду Сілва — як два блендери в кухні: все перемішають і подарують вам шедевр.

Тож моя думка: Португалія виграє цей “матч без королів”. Але це лише моя думка — а ваша? Пишіть у коментах!

304
38
0
DatenHeld_MUC
DatenHeld_MUCDatenHeld_MUC
1 month ago

Ohne die beiden Götter ist Portugal einfach stärker!

Mal ehrlich: Ohne Messi und Ronaldo sieht man endlich, wer wirklich Talent hat. Argentinien hat zwar Dibu im Tor (der Mann ist ein Monster!), aber Portugals Mittelfeld mit Bruno Fernandes und Bernardo Silva? Ein Traum!

Und die Stürmer? Lautaro und Álvarez sind klasse, aber Leão und Félix haben mehr Pep. Also, liebe Argentinien-Fans: Nicht böse sein, aber Zahlen lügen nicht.

Was denkt ihr? Schreibt’s in die Kommentare – aber bitte ohne Tränen!

348
22
0
Datenstürmer
DatenstürmerDatenstürmer
1 month ago

Ohne die Götter spielen die Sterblichen besser!

Mal ehrlich: Nimmt man Messi und Ronaldo raus, wird’s erst richtig spannend! Portugal hat mit Dias & Co. zwar die stabilere Abwehr, aber Argentiniens Dibu Martínez hält ja bekanntlich alles – sogar Schüsse von der Couch aus.

Das Midfield-Duell: Bruno Fernandes gegen Enzo Fernández? Da bekommt selbst mein Datenmodell Kopfschmerzen! Aber Portugal punktet klar mit mehr Kreativität – während Argentiniens Stürmerduo Álvarez/Martínez nur darauf wartet, dass irgendwer ihnen mal den Ball zuspielt.

Fazit? Portugal siegt… bis Diogo Jota sich wieder verletzt hust. Was sagt ihr – überschätze ich die portugiesische Defensive? Diskutiert gerne unten!

277
80
0
StatHysteria
StatHysteriaStatHysteria
1 month ago

Sans Messi et Ronaldo, qui domine ?

La question qui divise les fans ! L’Argentine a son duo d’attaque en or (Martínez et Álvarez) et un gardien monstrueux (Dibu), mais le Portugal répond avec une défense en béton et un milieu technique à faire pâlir d’envie.

Verdict ? Portugal, mais de justesse. Leur équilibre tactique fait la différence… même si les Argentins vont hurler au scandale !

Et vous, vous en pensez quoi ? Prêt à en découdre en commentaires ? 😏

491
71
0
WindyCityStats
WindyCityStatsWindyCityStats
1 month ago

Numbers don’t lie, but this one’s got trust issues

As a data guy, I crunched the stats: Portugal’s midfield is smoother than a jazz solo, but Argentina’s attack hits like a Bulls fastbreak. Still, that backline? Oof.

Verdict: Portugal wins… by the width of Dibu’s pinky finger.

Agree? My spreadsheets are ready for your hot takes.

704
34
0
FutebolLouco
FutebolLoucoFutebolLouco
1 month ago

Sem Messi e CR7, Portugal leva a melhor?

A análise tá boa, mas vamos combinar: se tirar um gênio de cada time, o jogo vira uma discussão de bar!

Argentina tem o Dibu (aquele que hipnotiza penalties) e dois atacantes de bilhões… mas o meio-campo de Portugal é tipo um enxame de abelhas tecnicamente talentosas! Bruno Fernandes + Bernardo Silva = caos organizado.

Veredito final: Portugal ganha… mas só no pênalti imaginário do meu humor duvidoso. Concordam ou vou levar pedradas nos comentários? 😂

185
52
0
SolDoTejo
SolDoTejoSolDoTejo
1 month ago

Sem Messi e Ronaldo, Portugal leva a melhor!

Olha só, se tirarmos os dois maiores da equação, a balança pende para Portugal! A defesa deles é uma muralha (Dias e companhia), e o meio-campo tem Bruno Fernandes e Bernardo Silva — pura magia técnica!

Já a Argentina? Bom, têm o Dibu no gol (herói eterno) e uns atacantes de respeito, mas… cadê a criatividade no meio?

No fim, é aquela briga de foice no escuro, mas Portugal ganha por um triz! E aí, concordam ou vou ouvir xingamentos nos comentários? 😂

376
100
0
শিরোনামহীন

আর্জেন্টিনা আর পর্তুগাল… কিন্তু মেসি-রোনাল্ডো নেই!

ওই দুই জাদুকর ছাড়া আসলেই কোন দল বেশি শক্তিশালী? আর্জেন্টিনার আছে ‘বিলিয়ন ডলার’ স্ট্রাইকার দুজন (মার্টিনেজ আর আলভারেজ), আর পর্তুগালের মিডফিল্ডে ব্রুনো ফার্নান্ডেসের মতো মাস্টারমাইন্ড!

সত্যি বলতে… পর্তুগালের ডিফেন্স আর মিডফিল্ড এতটাই শক্ত যে, আর্জেন্টিনার গোলকিপার ‘ডিবু’ মার্টিনেজও হয়তো ঘামতে শুরু করবেন!

হাসির লাইন: ‘মেসি-রোনাল্ডো না থাকলে পর্তুগালই জেতে!’ — এই তর্কে আপনিও যোগ দিন!

974
80
0
戰術板上的咖啡漬

數據會說話:葡萄牙贏面大

少了梅西跟C羅,這兩隊根本是「脫星版」的世紀對決啊!阿根廷前鋒線確實豪華,但葡萄牙那中後場簡直是「鋼鐵防線」加「魔術中場」的組合包。

門將vs中場的史詩級拉扯

雖然阿根廷有「聖馬丁尼」守門,但葡萄牙的B費+貝爾納多這對「技術宅組合」,根本是把足球當電玩在踢!

結論:五五波變六四開

原本以為勢均力敵,仔細看數據…葡萄牙贏面硬是多了一成啦!不服來辯~

76
10
0
LyonTactique
LyonTactiqueLyonTactique
1 month ago

Sans Messi et Ronaldo, le Portugal prend l’avantage !

La défense portugaise est une forteresse (Dias et Cancelo, bonjour !), et leur milieu de terrain joue comme un orchestre symphonique (Bruno Fernandes, chef d’orchestre en short).

L’Argentine a Dibu et ses deux bombardiers (Álvarez & Lautaro), mais avouons-le : sans Lionel, ils ont l’air d’un tango avec une jambe en moins.

Mon verdict ? Le Portugal par KO technique… ou devrais-je dire « par passe décisive de Bernardo Silva » ? 😉

Vous en pensez quoi, les footeux ?

982
97
0
brazilian football
Waltairondada vs Avaí: A 1-1 Draw That Tells a Story of Resilience and Data
1.0

Waltairondada vs Avaí: A 1-1 Draw That Tells a Story of Resilience and Data

Tough Draw: Vila Nova vs Avaí End in 1-1 Thriller at Baixada | A Match of Resilience and Redemption
1.0

Tough Draw: Vila Nova vs Avaí End in 1-1 Thriller at Baixada | A Match of Resilience and Redemption

Brazilian Serie B Week 12: Drama, Defense, and the Rise of the Underdogs
1.0

Brazilian Serie B Week 12: Drama, Defense, and the Rise of the Underdogs

Brazilian Serie B Week 12 Review: Drama, Data, and the Battle for Promotion
1.0

Brazilian Serie B Week 12 Review: Drama, Data, and the Battle for Promotion

Waltarredonda vs Avaí: A Tactical Clash That Ended in 1-1 Deadlock at the 2025 Copa do Brasil Final Stretch
1.0

Waltarredonda vs Avaí: A Tactical Clash That Ended in 1-1 Deadlock at the 2025 Copa do Brasil Final Stretch

Waltarena vs Avaí: A 1-1 Draw That Tells the Story of Brazilian Second Division’s Resilience
1.0

Waltarena vs Avaí: A 1-1 Draw That Tells the Story of Brazilian Second Division’s Resilience

Volta Redonda vs Avaí: A Battle of Resilience in Brazil's Serie B Showdown
1.0

Volta Redonda vs Avaí: A Battle of Resilience in Brazil's Serie B Showdown

Brazilian Serie B Round 12: Tactical Breakdown and Key Takeaways
1.0

Brazilian Serie B Round 12: Tactical Breakdown and Key Takeaways

Volta Redonda vs. Avaí: A Tactical Stalemate in Brazil's Serie B
1.0

Volta Redonda vs. Avaí: A Tactical Stalemate in Brazil's Serie B

Brazilian Serie B Round 12: Thrilling Draws, Surprising Upsets, and Playoff Implications
1.0

Brazilian Serie B Round 12: Thrilling Draws, Surprising Upsets, and Playoff Implications

football